Voter suppression includes both legal and illegal methods of preventing or discouraging voters from exercising their democratic right to vote. Overtly racist and violent voter suppression tactics, such as those used to keep African American voters from exercising their rights during the Jim Crow past, are not widespread today. However, there are new institutionalized barriers that can make voting more difficult for some communities.

According to the Brennan Center for Justice, since 2010, twenty-five states have passed laws that could make it more difficult to vote. Some of these laws include:

• Voter ID laws that require proof of address

• Laws that make it more difficult to register (and stay registered) to vote

• Laws limiting absentee voting

• Laws that make it hard for those with past criminal convictions to regain their voting rights

Research shows that these policies have a disproportionately negative effect on communities of color. Because of this, organizations and communities across the country are taking bold steps to overcome these barriers. As the United States approaches the 2020 national election, the articles in this collection provide important information on how organizers are engaging with communities of color in a way that respects and acknowledges a community’s culture and norms. Example initiatives covered in the collection include innovative and culturally specific ways to register people to vote, districts providing election day assistance to non-native English speaking populations, and the ways in which organizations are working to overcome voter ID laws that make it more difficult for residents of Native American nations to vote. Each of these examples of solutions journalism provide important insight into strategies that can be applied in other communities.

Student experience and critical analysis level: introductory

Utilize the three levels of analysis offered by Agenda-Setting Theory to analyze the four articles in this collection about racial equality and voter suppression. 

1. For each article, complete a first level analysis (what is media telling us to think about?).
2. For each article, complete a second level analysis (what is media telling us about which attributes are most important? What is being selected? Emphasized? Excluded? Elaborated upon?).
3. Complete a third-level analysis by viewing all of the articles together. In other words, when viewed as a complete collection, what issues do all four articles reveal to be related to racial equality and voter suppression? What are the commonalities across the four articles?
4. This collection is hosted and created by Solutions Journalism Network, a media nonprofit organization. With that third-level analysis in mind, what other kinds of media outlets typically bring together stories and news from multiple outlets to present a new or specific framing?

Article Summaries and Themes:

Design Culturally-Specific Get-Out-The-Vote Campaigns. Latinxs are one of the largest and fastest growing voter groups in Texas, but fewer than 41% cast a ballot in the 2016 election. Vicky Camarillo in the Corpus Christi Caller-Times shares several voter registration and education initiatives in Texas that incorporate the cultural norms of Latinx communities. Camarillo covers a variety of ways that organizations are engaging with the Latinx communities in Texas, including visiting Latinx-majority high schools, colleges and universities to register new voters and holding well attended Latinx-focused political candidate forums. One organization’s creative approach is to offer a free photo booth at quinceañera parties as long as they are paired with a voter registration table and the birthday girl makes a public speech pledging to vote when she turns 18 and calls on her guests to register to vote.

Provide Support for Non-Native English Speakers. Millions of Americans are at risk of being disenfranchised because they cannot access ballots or voter information in their native language. Asian-American and Latinx voters are particularly impacted by this. Alexa Ura reports in The Texas Tribune on an initiative in Harris County to help the 9,500 residents who speak Korean at home on election day. The county currently offers ballots in English, Spanish, Vietnamese, and Chinese, which are the native languages spoken by the county's four largest ethnic groups. There are other non-native English-speaking communities that, while not large enough to automatically qualify for ballots and voter information in their native language, still have a substantial number of voters that risk being disenfranchised due to language barriers. To help, the county clerk’s office decided to hire bilingual poll workers to assist native Korean speaking residents on election day.

Eliminate Barriers to Vote. Long lines to vote, restrictive voter ID laws, and a lack of early and absentee voting options are some of the barriers that disproportionately disenfranchise certain communities. Massoud Hayounv reports in Pacific Standard magazine on how Four Directions, a Native American voting rights organization, is targeting voter suppression and disenfranchisement by working in states that have both low Native American voter turnout and voter ID laws that require proof of address. Since most homes within Native American nations do not have formal addresses assigned to them, voter ID laws that require identification with an address keeps many Native Americans from being able to vote. While advocating to repeal these laws, the organization is also working to provide IDs to those living within Native American nations that meet the requirements of the laws. Similarly, Eric Cortellessa in Washington Monthly examines the impact of universal voting by mail on neighborhoods with lower incomes and communities of color. A special election in Maryland during the Covid-19 pandemic showed that turnout in Baltimore City, a majority African American community with lower incomes, increased by 6 percentage points with universal voting by mail. Organizers believe that this shows that voting by mail does not disenfranchise lower income communities of color, but rather removes some of the traditional barriers to voting such as having to take time off of work, waiting in long lines, and figuring out polling place location, especially with recent or frequent address changes.

original discussion questions

What are some explanations for the low voter turnout rates in Texas Latinx communities?

Because Latinx voters have consistently been disenfranchised, many feel that voting is a process designed for White, wealthy, educated populations, not all eligible citizens. Dislike of politicians also leads to a lack of engagement with the system rather than attempts to change it. A lack of information about candidates, registration processes, and polling procedures also contributes to low turnout.

 What steps are recommended by the National Vote at Home Institute to ease the transition to a mail-in election and increase voter participation?

The National Vote at Home Institute makes three primary recommendations: mail every voter a ballot (as opposed to telling voters to request a ballot, which reduces overall turnout); keep a limited number of polling places open for voters who need them, including people with disabilities and without access to mail; and invest in equipment like high-speed vote counters to accommodate the ballots and ease the process.

Voter participation campaigns are more successful when they are tailored to a specific cultural group rather than applied indiscriminately to the entire populace. Compare and contrast the different approaches illustrated by diverse cultural and ethnic communities within this collection.

Some voters, like Hyunja Norman, must adapt to voting procedures that veer away from their own cultural norms; Norman explained that while she was growing up in South Korea, she was always taught to blend into the crowd and avoid drawing attention to herself. However, “[she] realized to live in America, we cannot live the way we lived in our old country... We have to make our voice heard. We need to make noise." Other communities find success by integrating civic participation into their cultural celebrations, such as Poder Quince in Texas. Girls who are hosting quinceañeras in Austin, Dallas and Houston can apply to receive a free photo booth for their party (as well as Snapchat filters), which helps draw attention to a voter registration table. During her thank-you speech, the birthday girl pledges to vote when she’s of age and calls on her guests to register to vote. The program draws in teenage Latinx voters while also reaching out to the aunts, uncles and grandparents who have typically shied away from politics.

How do Voter ID laws prevent Native Americans from participating in elections?

To get an ID, individuals typically need a permanent address that meets specific government regulations. Many Native voters, however, live in rural areas without specific street names, let alone full addresses. Without an address, it is significantly more difficult to get an ID; without the ID, they are disenfranchised.

One of the Solutions Journalism Network Success Factors is "empowering people: building the confidence and problem-solving abilities of communities." Select one of the stories included in this collection and assess it based a Success Factor subcategory of your choosing: focusing on assets instead of need; local control/ownership; resilience; or raising expectations.

Answers will vary.